Tags
Chapel of the Holy Trinity, chastity belts, Chlamydia trachomatis, Cryptosporidium, Cultural Marxism, Deconstructionism, Dr. Curt Doolittle, Father Anthony Cekada, Fox News, Francis Effect, FrancisChurch - In Liquidation, Frankfurt School, FSSP, Genderism, George Soros, Germany, Giardia lamblia, Gonorrhea, Great Cardinal, Havana, Hemorrhoids, heretical pope, Herpes simplex virus, hippies, HIV, Holy Year of Mercy, Human immunodeficiency virus, Human papilloma virus, Humanism, Isospora belli, Jacque Derrida, James O'Keefe, Jesuits, Jesus Christ, Joseph Ratzinger, Jozef Pilsudski, Keynes, Keynesian Economics, Kirill I, Krakow, Law of Unintended Consequences, messeging, Mexico City, Microsporidia, Miracle on the Vistula, Modernists, MSM, narratives, Nassim Taleb, neo-modernism, Neo-Pagan, Net Neutrality, new springtime, New York Times, Nigel Farage, Pagan Christians, pathological, Poland, Polish Bolshevik War 1920, Pontifical High Mass, Pope Pius VI, President Andrzej Duda, Project Veritas, r/K Selection Theory, Raymond Burke, Republic of Poland, retained foreign bodies, risk event, Roman Curia, s "c"atholicZombie, s "theological structuring", s ABC News, s ABERRO AGENDA, s aberro-sex agenda, s AIDS, s Ambiguity, s Anal Cancer, s anorectal traum, s Archbishop of Warsaw- Praga, s Associated Press, s Austria, s Benedict XVI, s Bergoglio, s Big Gender, s Bio-History, s Boris Johnson, s BREXIT, s Card. Muller, s Cardinal Burke, s Cardinal Kazimierz Nycz, s cardinal Walter Kasper, s Catholic Church, s Pope Francis, Saul Alinsky, sCatholic Church in Poland, Sexually transmitted diseases, spirit of Vatican II, SSPX, St Thomas Aquinas, sustainability, Synod 2014, Synod of Filth, Syphilis25, Tags anal fissures, Tags Black Lives Matter, Team Bergoglio, The Remnant, The Scholasticum, theological deconstructionism, Thomism, Tradition, TransRational, Truth, Unjust ruler, Vatican II, Work of Human Hands, Zombie, ZombieBishop, ZombieChurch
Now that the talks between TeamFrancis, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and the SSPX have been returned to a rational, logically coherent and sustainable position, i.e. square one, a timely post appeared on the SSPX’s US District website. (see below)
What I think is of significance in this post is that it is beginning to dawn on everyone concerned and all Catholics of good will, that the approach to resolve the situation of the post Vatican II crisis in the Catholic Church will be very similar to the one Archbishop Lefebvre provided 40 years earlier.
The further significance of this OBSERVATION is that it is becoming clear that the Lefebvre Solution appears to be a UNIVERSAL solution. In other words, it is the solution that will bring the most optimal outcome EVERYWHERE, ALWAYS and for EVERYONE.
Aside from the above, a video that I have embedded at the top of this post does a very good job of explaining the problem that a theology (a real theology and there can be but one) will experience if it detaches itself from a rational philosophical understanding of the nature of OBJECTIVE REALITY.
Naturally, the presenter does not mention Catholicism by name, but rather makes a general case for Christianity. In reality however, the observations apply exclusively to the ONE TRUE FAITH. The reason being is that only Catholicism has a comprehensive understanding of the nature of His creation, drawing its belief system from not only “divine revelation”, but also from the “natural light of human reason from the things that are made”.
Summa summarum, sole scriptura is just not enough.
PS Hat tip to Armitage Smyth for providing the link to the video above.
When Others Follow the Society‘s Example
In a recent interview with National Catholic Register, former consulter to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Monsignor Nicola Bux unexpectedly echoed the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX)’s position on the widespread crisis of the faith within the Church.
The interview was composed of just three questions all centered on what the Register describes as the “doctrinal anarchy” in the Church and its consequences for the Mystical Body of Christ.
Bux sees the spirit of division that affects the Church at her highest level as a consequence of the present doctrinal confusion: “When cardinals are silent or accuse their confreres; when bishops who had thought, spoken and written in a Catholic way, but then say the opposite for whatever reason; when priests contest the liturgical tradition of the Church, then apostasy is established, the detachment from Catholic thought.”
According to the former consulter on the liturgy, only strongly recalling the principal dogmatic truths can bring peace back to the Church: “This is the role of the Magisterium, founded on the truth of Christ: to bring everyone back to Catholic unity.”
Secondly, Bux was asked about the consequences of this “doctrinal anarchy” for the faithful. The liturgy professor from Bari recalled the danger of adopting the false values of the world: “when one is applauded by the world, it means one belongs to it. May the Catholic Church always remember that she is made up of only those who have converted to Christ under the guidance of the Holy Spirit; all human beings are ordained to her, but they are not part of her until they are converted.”
In the third and last question, the Register asked about the ways to help remedy this confusion. Bux believes the pope needs to act without delay and make a distinction between his pontifical function whose goal is to confirm the faith of the faithful, and his private person: “To be clear: the Pope can express his ideas as a private learned person on disputable matters which are not defined by the Church, but he cannot make heretical claims, even privately. Otherwise it would be equally heretical”
Cardinal Sarah’s former collaborator explained that in the Church there exists a sensus fidei, a sort of supernatural common sense that makes every believer capable of sensing “what the faith of the Church is”; and in this sense, “even one believer can hold [the sovereign pontiff] to account.”
This remark led Bux to broach the question of legitimate doubts on a matter related to the deposit of the Faith that can be submitted to the supreme authority in the Church: “So whoever thinks that presenting doubts (dubia) to the Pope is not a sign of obedience, hasn’t understood, 50 years after Vatican II, the relationship between [the Pope] and the whole Church.” A sort of response to those who reproach the four cardinals for asking the Holy Father to clarify the more controversial parts of the post-synodal exhortation Amoris Laetitia.
Just as the SSPX keeps repeating through the voice of its Superior General, the prelate concluded that “obedience to the Pope depends solely on the fact that he is bound by Catholic doctrine, to the faith that he must continually profess before the Church.” Which is why Mgr. Bux voiced his desire for “the Pope — like Paul VI (June 30, 1968 Ed. Note) — to make a Declaration or Profession of Faith, affirming what is Catholic, and correcting those ambiguous and erroneous words and acts — his own and those of bishops — that are interpreted in a non-Catholic manner.”
These remarks from a specialist on the liturgy are along the same lines as the positions defended by the Society, and sound like an echo of what Bishop Fellay declared in his Letter to Friends and Benefactors in November 2010: “Archbishop Lefebvre’s path is still of the present moment. What he said thirty, forty years ago is still perfectly pertinent today. This demands of us a great gratitude to God for having given us – and to the whole Church – such a bishop. There is no doubt that, if in the Church his precious indications were followed, the whole Mystical Body would be better off and would soon come out of this crisis.”
Michael Dowd said:
Thanks S.A. Outstanding video. Mr. E. has it exactly right. Pope Francis is leading us to a one world religion where man will be worshiped, not God. Since we are so far along on this road to perdition I see no other answer than divine intervention. Hopefully, it will happen very soon with minimum damage to the innocent.
LikeLike
Cold Standing said:
A L L A H
Arm
Leg
Leg
Arm
Head.
It is already here.
… and God has already intervened. His means of salvation is still effective.
… original sin… nobody is innocent.
LikeLike
Ritter der Immaculata said:
~What is also of importance is how the c[C]hurch is just part and parcel of the wider war. SA
No. The Church is the whole war of the world. These other phenomena of society are a manifestation of either false religions, or the true Religion. If you had to chose only one means of ‘fixing’ the world, you would do well to fix the clergy of the Religion that steers the world. Why does She govern the world? Because ideas matter, the Church takes ideas seriously and Her ideas have primacy over all others.
In all other religions no one cares what you believe in as long as you go along to get along, the Devil doesn’t care what your delusion is as long as it robs you of God. The Popes however, used to care immensely what you believe in because it pertains to your eternal destiny and even their own if they would fail to stay true to their duty even to the shedding of blood. That’s how you come to understand the Catholic Faith as essentially unique.
LikeLike
S. Armaticus said:
I would even reduce it further and, like Fr. Z, say that through saving the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, we can save the world.
Everything you write above is OBJECTIVELY CORRECT.
LikeLike
Wanda said:
In 10 minutes, the Rocking Philosophy video gives us an excellent primer on the current destruction of Christianity. There is enough info in here to give even the most bored and uninterested citizen an opportunity to think a little more deeply than they do. Msgr. Bux, obviously of the old school, also lays bare for us the glaring inconsistencies and, let’s be honest here, the heretical drift we are currently experiencing. It seems that the Holy Spirit is, thankfully, at work. God be praised.
LikeLike
S. Armaticus said:
I agree. This video needs to be watched multiple times and studied. It lays out the problem and the solution simultaneously. What is also of importance is how the church is just part and parcel of the wider war.
LikeLike
Pingback: Canon212 Update: The Western Schism Shows Us That These Things Can Be Resolved When You Try – The Stumbling Block
Michael Dowd said:
S.A. The conditions required recently by the Vatican for SSPX to return to full communion with the Church do not appear favorable. What do you think?
LikeLike